Welcome to Mill Creek Insurance

Keeping Our Promise

Keeping Our Promise

At Mill Creek Insurance Agency, we keep our promises to you. And we’ve been keeping our promises to offer affordable insurance backed by service with integrity to your neighbors and friends in Union and surrounding counties since 1938.

Celina Pay

Pay Your Bills Online!

Part of our promise to you is that life will always be a little easier with Mill Creek Insurance. Now you can pay your bills – Celina, Motorists, Wayne, Foremost, and Hagerty,  online with just a click above – try it out today!

Our Business

Our Business

At Mill Creek Insurance we understand that as a business owner you always don’t have the time to thoroughly understand all of the different coverage’s available for your business.



Emergency Contact Information

Need to reach one of our providers after hours? Here is a list of numbers for each provider:

  • Motorists – 800-876-8766
  • Celina – 800.231.2318
  • Wayne – 1-800-222-3873 x1 then x8
  • Foremost – 1-800-527-3907 (Except Auto) , 1-800-274-7865 (Foremost Auto)
  • Hagerty – 1-877-922-9701 Option 5
Latest from the blog
Welcome to Mill Creek Insurance

We are here to provide you with top notch insurance! We are located in Marysville OH….


Looking to find coverage for that restored muscle car?


We can help! Americans have a passion for the automobile, a passion that our staff and agents at Mill Creek Insurance understand. We work for you to insure that your financial interest in your automobile will be covered in the event of an accident. Click Here to get a quote today!